BYPASS

The subcontractor wins an adjudication against the main contractor, and asks the employer to pay him the awarded amount.  The employer says it does not owe money to the main contractor, because it has claims against the main contractor after terminating the main contract.  The main contractor disputes the termination.  Will the courts – in the subcontractor’s direct payment application – decide who is right and who is wrong in the main contract dispute in order to ascertain whether money is owed to the main contractor (and hence can be paid directly to the subcontractor)?  The Court of Appeal dealt with this recently in JDI Buildtech (M) Sdn Bhd v Danga Jed Development Malaysia Sdn Bhd [2024] CLJU 373. Continue reading “BYPASS” →

ROUNDABOUT

Can the winner of a foreign arbitration seek to enforce the arbitral award in Malaysia as a foreign judgment, after converting the award to a judgment abroad?  If so, in resisting enforcement of the judgment, can the losing party raise grounds for challenging the award?  Apparent so, says the Court of Appeal in Tumpuan Megah Development Sdn Bhd v ING Bank NV [2024] CLJU 42. Continue reading “ROUNDABOUT” →

ASSESSING REASONABLE TIME

How does one assess reasonable time, in a way that will not allow the employer to take advantage of its own fault, and also not give the contractor more time than that caused by the employer’s delay?  Guidance was provided recently by the Appellate Division of the Singapore High Court in ICOP Construction (SG) Pte Ltd v Tiong Seng Civil Engineering (Pte) Ltd [2024] SGHC(A) 1. Continue reading “ASSESSING REASONABLE TIME” →

AVOID LAD BY BREACHING THE CONTRACT

From the recent Court of Appeal decision in Rumaya Properties Sdn Bhd v Seacera Development Sdn Bhd [2023] 6 AMR 781, it appears possible to avoid liquidated and ascertained damages (“LAD”) by disabling oneself from performing and breaching the contract. Continue reading “AVOID LAD BY BREACHING THE CONTRACT” →

WHO IS THE EMPLOYER?

There is usually no doubt as to who the employer is under the construction contract.  But once in a while, a case like G-Pile System Sdn Bhd v CMMC Sdn Bhd [2021] 1 LNS 1727 comes along to show how things can go wrong when roles are fluid and proper documentation is lacking. Continue reading “WHO IS THE EMPLOYER?” →

AFFIRM CONTRACT, LOSE LAD

Affirming a construction contract – instead of terminating it due to the contractor’s delay – resulted in the loss of entitlement to liquidated and ascertained damages (“LAD”).  This was one of the grounds for dismissing a LAD claim in the recent High Court case of  Universiti Tecknologi MARA v Magna Metier Sdn Bhd [2022] 5 AMR 583. Continue reading “AFFIRM CONTRACT, LOSE LAD” →

CONCURRENT DELAY & REASONABLE TIME

Concurrent delay is usually considered in the context of extension of time (“EOT”) to complete construction works.  In RC Asia Engineering Sdn Bhd v Lion Pacific Sdn Bhd [2021] 1 LNS 1667 however, the High Court had occasion to consider concurrent delay – or overlapping delay – in the assessment of reasonable time to complete such works. Continue reading “CONCURRENT DELAY & REASONABLE TIME” →

BEING LATE FOR MANY REASONS

For concurrent delay, do you look at cause?  Or effect?  Or both?  “Effect” is the answer indicated by the Queensland Supreme Court in Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd [2017] QSC 85 (“Civil Mining”). Continue reading “BEING LATE FOR MANY REASONS” →

LOOK FORWARD OR LOOK BACK?

Causation of delay in construction disputes is usually the subject of expert evidence, in the form of a delay analysis of the project.  The entire project duration is analysed, to establish the cause and effect of delay events encountered.  The analysis is relevant to determine entitlements to extension of time (“EOT”) to complete the works, and compensation for delays. The perennial issue that commonly arises is whether the analysis should be prospective or retrospective. Continue reading “LOOK FORWARD OR LOOK BACK?” →