THE CUBIC PUZZLE & LIQUIDATED DAMAGES IV – BACK TO THE PAST?

In the recent case of Tekun Nasional Sdn Bhd v Plenitude Drive (M) Sdn Bhd [2021] 8 AMR 427, the Federal Court (“FC“) appears to conflate the concepts under the old and new law as to how section 75, Contracts Act 1950 is to be applied to liquidated damages clauses.

Tekun appointed Plenitude to design, develop and supply hardware, software and technology for a system to collect loan repayments (see para 10).  The agreement between them contained a clause 11.2 which provided for the payment of compensation if the agreement is unilaterally terminated by either party before its expiry.  The compensation is for loss of income for the remaining term of the agreement, and the amount of compensation is to be calculated according to the formula stipulated in the clause.  See paras 44, 47.

Tekun had unilaterally terminated the agreement.  This led to Plenitude suing Tekun for compensation pursuant to clause 11.2.  The FC applied s 75, Contracts Act 1950 to Plenitude’s claim.  In particular, the FC found that the previous law relating to s 75 is applicable – i.e. the law before the FC case of Cubic Electronics Sdn Bhd v Mars Telecommunications Sdn Bhd [2019] 1 AMR 723 – as the full trial had already been completed before Cubic was decided.  See paras 35, 38 and 44.

Under the previous law, a claimant has to prove its actual losses notwithstanding any agreed compensation / damages clause (subject to an exception which is not relevant here).  As Plenitude failed to prove any actual loss, the FC allowed only nominal damages of RM5,000 (as opposed to the claim amount of RM29.8 million).  See paras 35, 67 and 74.

Although the FC was applying the previous law, the FC mentioned concepts that were introduced into Malaysian law by Cubic.  The FC said that the courts have to consider whether the amount calculated based on the damages clause is “proportionate” to the “legitimate interest” of the innocent party; see paras 56 and 63.  The concepts of “proportionality” and “legitimate interest” were introduced in Cubic, and were not applied in prior cases.

Those concepts were utilized to move away from the previous emphasis on proof of actual loss.  In Cubic, claims for amounts calculated according to the damages clause will be allowed where such amounts are proportionate to the legitimate interest sought to be protected by the said clause.  By using concepts that are more ambiguous and subjective as compared to strict proof of actual loss, the agreed damages amount is to be upheld, unless such amount is “exorbitant”.

Given that backdrop, it is therefore ironic that “proportionality” and “legitimate interest” appear to be now conflated with that of proving actual loss in this latest FC decision.  Perhaps there is a subtle shift in the judicial wind on this subject, but that remains to be seen.

For previous posts on Cubic, click here for Cubic Puzzle I, here for Cubic Puzzle 2 and here for Cubic Puzzle 3.

The contents of this article are published for the purpose of general information only; they are not to be regarded, used or relied on as legal advice for any matter.  Please contact us if you require legal advice specific to your case.